{
  "artifact": "GEAIRM-A11 Negative / Semantic Boundary Test Cases",
  "version": "0.1",
  "status": "informative-deterministic-negative-test-fixtures",
  "normativeSource": "docs/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1-specification.md",
  "sourceStage": "GEAIRM-M16 / GEAIRM-A10",
  "testStage": "GEAIRM-A11",
  "purpose": "Deterministic negative and semantic-boundary fixtures for later automated execution by A12 while preserving the distinction between machine-detectable violations and assessment-required semantic rejection.",
  "counts": {
    "totalNegativeTestcases": 36,
    "canonicalSemanticCounterexamples": 15,
    "a6ExecutableBoundaryTestcases": 9,
    "a7StructuralBoundaryTestcases": 6,
    "a8ProfileExtensionBoundaryTestcases": 6,
    "machineExpectedFailTestcases": 21,
    "machinePassButSemanticRejectTestcases": 15
  },
  "executionContract": {
    "authoritativeDiscovery": "Use this manifest; do not infer the suite from directory enumeration.",
    "negativeMeaning": "A negative testcase is expected to be rejected at its declared validation boundary. It is not required that every negative fail JSON Schema or SHACL.",
    "semanticCounterexampleContract": "M16-C01 through M16-C15 are intentionally A7-valid and A6-PASS fixtures whose invalid inference must be rejected by semantic assessment. A6 PASS must not be promoted to semantic conformance.",
    "a6BoundaryContract": "A6 executable-boundary fixtures are RDF/Turtle deltas evaluated against the A4 baseline graph and must yield the declared SHACL violation.",
    "schemaBoundaryContract": "A7/A8 boundary fixtures are valid JSON but must fail the declared schema.",
    "conformanceBoundary": "Rejection of a counterexample or machine-negative does not prove the remainder of a model instance fully conformant."
  },
  "testcases": [
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-001",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C01",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P01",
      "title": "Model Product dependency does not imply Derived APT",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c01-model-product-dependency-does-not-imply-derived-apt.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p01-primary-learned-model-fraud.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "FraudProduct-v2.1 materiallyDependsOn FraudModel-v4, therefore APT = Derived.",
      "rejectionReason": "A Model Product / AI Primitive dependency does not by itself establish material upstream AI Product intelligence provenance required for Derived classification.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-004",
          "title": "AI Product Non-Inference",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_004_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-007",
          "title": "Classification Orthogonality",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_007_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-008",
          "title": "Occurrence/Product Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_008_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-009",
          "title": "Product-Property Scope",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "HybridAssessmentRequired",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-012",
          "title": "No Dependency Inheritance",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_012_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-025",
          "title": "Effect Non-Productization",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_025_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "b13cd071c6ef9f840502b407df90684d87d563caa934000634bee1fc376ad1a4"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-002",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C02",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P02",
      "title": "Productized learned model does not automatically become AI Product",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c02-productized-learned-model-does-not-automatically-become-ai-produ.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p02-productized-model-boundary.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "QwenLikeModel-v7 is sold commercially and uses learned AI technology, therefore it is an AIPS AI Product.",
      "rejectionReason": "Business role, learned mechanism and BPS Product status do not bypass AIPS AI Product qualification.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-003",
          "title": "Product Non-Inference",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_003_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-004",
          "title": "AI Product Non-Inference",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_004_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-005",
          "title": "Role Non-Intrinsicality",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "HybridAssessmentRequired",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-007",
          "title": "Classification Orthogonality",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_007_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-012",
          "title": "No Dependency Inheritance",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_012_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "a8491566762955918c42eb9bf5fefb07e97a7a9981553cef1a4f8064108fb392"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-003",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C03",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P03",
      "title": "No ML/retraining does not exclude symbolic AI",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c03-no-ml-retraining-does-not-exclude-symbolic-ai.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p03-symbolic-policy-reasoner.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "PolicyReasonerProduct-v1.3 has learningMode NONE, therefore it cannot be an AI Product.",
      "rejectionReason": "GEAIRM/AIPS semantics are mechanism-neutral; symbolic AI does not require learned-model retraining.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-007",
          "title": "Classification Orthogonality",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_007_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-012",
          "title": "No Dependency Inheritance",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_012_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-017",
          "title": "Agent/AI Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_017_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-036",
          "title": "Architecture Boundary",
          "validationClass": "assessment-only",
          "machineCheckability": "none",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "AssessmentOnly",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "8dd673c9025c9cee2756bd709ec1960728f5bc272c76f04e19b33554be3bc362"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-004",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C04",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P04",
      "title": "Retrieval does not imply trusted grounding or correctness",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c04-retrieval-does-not-imply-trusted-grounding-or-correctness.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p04-grounded-generation.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "Retrieval retrieves K, therefore K is trusted grounding evidence and the result is factually correct.",
      "rejectionReason": "Retrieval, grounding participation, source authority, evidence sufficiency and factual correctness are separate assertions.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-002",
          "title": "Identity Preservation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "HybridAssessmentRequired",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-005",
          "title": "Role Non-Intrinsicality",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "HybridAssessmentRequired",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-010",
          "title": "Context Qualification",
          "validationClass": "assessment-only",
          "machineCheckability": "none",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "AssessmentOnly",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-011",
          "title": "No Lexical Equivalence",
          "validationClass": "assessment-only",
          "machineCheckability": "none",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "AssessmentOnly",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-019",
          "title": "Tool/Authority Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_019_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-027",
          "title": "Evidence Non-Proof",
          "validationClass": "assessment-only",
          "machineCheckability": "none",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "AssessmentOnly",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "4ed68a0b580ccb571b033068dda2ad1f66b3fc2e7b96da40dfa6e1df2e43b9e2"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-005",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C05",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P05",
      "title": "Tool use does not transfer Product governance, risk or authority",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c05-tool-use-does-not-transfer-product-governance-risk-or-authority.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p05-agent-tool-use.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "Agent uses AI Product as Tool, therefore Agent inherits Product governance profile, risk tier and action authority.",
      "rejectionReason": "Dependency or Tool participation does not transfer Product governance, risk classification, entitlement or authority.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-001",
          "title": "Authority Preservation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_001_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-002",
          "title": "Identity Preservation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "HybridAssessmentRequired",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-012",
          "title": "No Dependency Inheritance",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_012_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-017",
          "title": "Agent/AI Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_017_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-018",
          "title": "Autonomy/Authority Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_018_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-019",
          "title": "Tool/Authority Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_019_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "a617d812d58805f012da7037140c11c3bce75806e9600d9382abe66d04dfb5b1"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-006",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C06",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P06",
      "title": "Human presence does not prove review, acceptance or authorization",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c06-human-presence-does-not-prove-review-acceptance-or-authorization.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p06-human-reviewed-recommendation.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "AI produced RecommendationEffect and a Human Agent was present, therefore the recommendation was reviewed, accepted and authorized.",
      "rejectionReason": "Human participation does not itself establish review, acceptance, Decision Formation or Authorization.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-018",
          "title": "Autonomy/Authority Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_018_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-020",
          "title": "Instruction/Authority Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_020_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-023",
          "title": "Decision/Authority Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_023_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-024",
          "title": "No Mandatory Decision Pipeline",
          "validationClass": "assessment-only",
          "machineCheckability": "none",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "AssessmentOnly",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-025",
          "title": "Effect Non-Productization",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_025_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "41a4d6239936e52b34ce198b041b79b6d97fbf64e65bcaacf5b38f28bf56a8d6"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-007",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C07",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P07",
      "title": "AutonomousAction does not imply unrestricted authority",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c07-autonomousaction-does-not-imply-unrestricted-authority.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p07-autonomous-digital-action.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "Product has AR=AutonomousAction, therefore it may invoke any Tool and perform any digital action without scope constraints.",
      "rejectionReason": "Agency/Autonomy classification remains separate from Delegated Authority, Authorization, policy and scope.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-018",
          "title": "Autonomy/Authority Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_018_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-019",
          "title": "Tool/Authority Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_019_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-023",
          "title": "Decision/Authority Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_023_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-024",
          "title": "No Mandatory Decision Pipeline",
          "validationClass": "assessment-only",
          "machineCheckability": "none",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "AssessmentOnly",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-025",
          "title": "Effect Non-Productization",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_025_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-029",
          "title": "Risk/Governance Authority",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_029_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "08796bd237789de3cf49a4b370dbd1c00aa5f7609c6111ad0de138c7f244eb40"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-008",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C08",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P08",
      "title": "Environment interaction does not imply Product Embodiment or authorization",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c08-environment-interaction-does-not-imply-product-embodiment-or-aut.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p08-closed-loop-physical-ai.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "Execution acts upon Environment, therefore Product is ClosedLoopAutonomous and every physical action is authorized.",
      "rejectionReason": "Occurrence-level interaction does not establish Product-version Embodiment and does not establish Authorization.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-008",
          "title": "Occurrence/Product Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_008_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-018",
          "title": "Autonomy/Authority Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_018_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-021",
          "title": "Sensing/Perception Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_021_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-022",
          "title": "Actuation/Action Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_022_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-025",
          "title": "Effect Non-Productization",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_025_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-029",
          "title": "Risk/Governance Authority",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_029_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "ce1b6ea72d0d852884fcbe08bcd00a7cc6200fe7818ce82157ce1ec845733c05"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-009",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C09",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P09",
      "title": "Runtime calls do not imply Composite Derived AI Product",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c09-runtime-calls-do-not-imply-composite-derived-ai-product.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p09-derived-composite-risk.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "Service calls three AI Products, therefore Service is a Composite Derived AI Product.",
      "rejectionReason": "Runtime calls do not establish BPS Productness, AIPS qualification, material AI Product provenance or a distinct governed intelligence proposition.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-003",
          "title": "Product Non-Inference",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_003_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-004",
          "title": "AI Product Non-Inference",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_004_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-012",
          "title": "No Dependency Inheritance",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_012_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-015",
          "title": "Composition Non-Inheritance",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_015_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-016",
          "title": "Runtime Composition Non-Productization",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_016_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "b81f6645f2a8943f0593513663453cec4eb1418c9bb25b172787ae9da9492e65"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-010",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C10",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P10",
      "title": "Orchestration does not create new AI Product identity",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c10-orchestration-does-not-create-new-ai-product-identity.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p10-runtime-orchestration.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "Orchestration coordinates two AI Products, therefore Orchestration is a Derived Composite AI Product.",
      "rejectionReason": "Runtime Orchestration is not itself a Product or AI Product absent independent BPS/AIPS qualification.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-002",
          "title": "Identity Preservation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "HybridAssessmentRequired",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-003",
          "title": "Product Non-Inference",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_003_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-004",
          "title": "AI Product Non-Inference",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_004_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-015",
          "title": "Composition Non-Inheritance",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_015_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-016",
          "title": "Runtime Composition Non-Productization",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_016_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "3006698402121d18e81d3c90f6e14270b619bb95f164e4f763aa0f6b0db4bef3"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-011",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C11",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P11",
      "title": "Multi-Agent Composition does not imply Collective Agent or union authority",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c11-multi-agent-composition-does-not-imply-collective-agent-or-union.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p11-multi-agent-composition.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "Three Agents participate in Composition, therefore Composition is one Autonomous Cognitive Collective Agent with union permissions.",
      "rejectionReason": "Composition does not transfer Agent identity or authority; Collective Agent identity and authority require independent qualification.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-002",
          "title": "Identity Preservation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "HybridAssessmentRequired",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-005",
          "title": "Role Non-Intrinsicality",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "HybridAssessmentRequired",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-017",
          "title": "Agent/AI Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_017_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-018",
          "title": "Autonomy/Authority Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_018_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-019",
          "title": "Tool/Authority Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_019_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "9643879c7962afe35a9d263e48ab2d4bdbf7a6e668c9d23623b42a3006277411"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-012",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C12",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P12",
      "title": "AI dependency does not transfer Product Family",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c12-ai-dependency-does-not-transfer-product-family.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p12-ai-enabled-service-product.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "AI Product dependency is essential, therefore containing Service inherits AI Product Family.",
      "rejectionReason": "Dependencies and composition do not transfer intrinsic Product Family under BPS/PIN.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-003",
          "title": "Product Non-Inference",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_003_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-004",
          "title": "AI Product Non-Inference",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_004_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-012",
          "title": "No Dependency Inheritance",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_012_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-015",
          "title": "Composition Non-Inheritance",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_015_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "dbc9a09ac310c88075f5dd214885fed58ebc0c474ba19985f4ad5078bcc93025"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-013",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C13",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P13",
      "title": "Evaluation/Assurance success does not determine Effective Risk Tier",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c13-evaluation-assurance-success-does-not-determine-effective-risk-t.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p13-evaluation-assurance-risk.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "All evaluation criteria passed, therefore Product risk tier must be reduced to R0.",
      "rejectionReason": "Evaluation and Assurance do not directly determine AIPS Effective Risk Tier.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-026",
          "title": "Evaluation/Assurance Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_026_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-027",
          "title": "Evidence Non-Proof",
          "validationClass": "assessment-only",
          "machineCheckability": "none",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "AssessmentOnly",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-028",
          "title": "Assurance/Risk Orthogonality",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_028_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-029",
          "title": "Risk/Governance Authority",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_029_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-030",
          "title": "Obligation/Control Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "HybridAssessmentRequired",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "ab06252a18763ef4e09bb7211a29160fda23bbfcc60f7bdb2926ae3aaa19976f"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-014",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C14",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P14",
      "title": "Newer upstream version does not rewrite historical dependency binding",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c14-newer-upstream-version-does-not-rewrite-historical-dependency-bi.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p14-dependency-currentness.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "U4 is newer than U3, therefore every historical D7->U3 dependency is replaced by D7->U4.",
      "rejectionReason": "Later upstream availability/currentness changes do not mutate historical dependency assertions.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-012",
          "title": "No Dependency Inheritance",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_012_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-013",
          "title": "Path not Transitivity",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_013_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-031",
          "title": "Identity/Version Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_031_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-032",
          "title": "Historical Non-Mutation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "HybridAssessmentRequired",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-033",
          "title": "Currentness Contextuality",
          "validationClass": "assessment-only",
          "machineCheckability": "none",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "AssessmentOnly",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-035",
          "title": "Provenance/Dependency Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_035_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "05fccc1ae6bc76fded5742562165717ce1c37a722bafb5c575374bc9e7fdb3b6"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SEM-015",
      "category": "CANONICAL_SEMANTIC_COUNTEREXAMPLE",
      "sourceCounterexampleId": "M16-C15",
      "sourcePatternId": "M16-P15",
      "title": "Later reclassification does not rewrite historical Product Family",
      "inputFile": "negative/semantic/m16-c15-later-reclassification-does-not-rewrite-historical-product-famil.json",
      "sourcePositiveFixture": "positive/m16-p15-version-reclassification.json",
      "invalidInferenceUnderTest": "A-v2 removes the final AI Primitive, therefore rewrite A-v1 Product Family from AI Product to conventional software Product.",
      "rejectionReason": "Later version reclassification does not rewrite historically true Product-family classification of an earlier version.",
      "applicableInvariants": [
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-004",
          "title": "AI Product Non-Inference",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_004_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-031",
          "title": "Identity/Version Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_031_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-032",
          "title": "Historical Non-Mutation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "HybridAssessmentRequired",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-033",
          "title": "Currentness Contextuality",
          "validationClass": "assessment-only",
          "machineCheckability": "none",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "AssessmentOnly",
          "a6CoverageShape": null,
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-034",
          "title": "Supersession History Preservation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_034_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        },
        {
          "id": "GEAIRM-INV-035",
          "title": "Provenance/Dependency Separation",
          "validationClass": "hybrid-assessment",
          "machineCheckability": "partial",
          "a6CoverageStatus": "PartialExecutable",
          "a6CoverageShape": "GEAIRM_INV_035_Shape",
          "semanticAssessmentRequired": true
        }
      ],
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS",
          "interpretation": "A6 covers only safely executable portions; PASS must not validate the counterexample semantic inference."
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "DOES_NOT_CONFORM",
          "required": true
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "3dd74abbd45f9cca1e54274da9c4e3ca539410f8b18b78adb9f499877350bbc3"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SHACL-001",
      "category": "A6_EXECUTABLE_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Tool explicitly equated with Product",
      "inputFile": "negative/shacl/a6-001-tool-explicitly-equated-with-product.ttl",
      "applicableInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-003",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "RDF_TURTLE_PARSE",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "dataBaseline": "../geairm-0.1.ttl + fixture",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL",
          "expectedInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-003"
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "NOT_REQUIRED_TO_ESTABLISH_THIS_EXPLICIT_MACHINE_VIOLATION",
          "note": "Broader semantic conformance remains outside the machine result."
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "6dde360db695ea0ceef16c1bb5a5ee84f50d8396d78e6715a4b73d1d728e0cc0",
      "observedA11ViolationCount": 2,
      "observedA11ViolationMessages": [
        "GEAIRM-INV-003: Tool/Composition must not be explicitly collapsed into Product or AI Product identity."
      ]
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SHACL-002",
      "category": "A6_EXECUTABLE_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "AI Primitive explicitly equated with AI Product",
      "inputFile": "negative/shacl/a6-002-ai-primitive-explicitly-equated-with-ai-product.ttl",
      "applicableInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-004",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "RDF_TURTLE_PARSE",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "dataBaseline": "../geairm-0.1.ttl + fixture",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL",
          "expectedInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-004"
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "NOT_REQUIRED_TO_ESTABLISH_THIS_EXPLICIT_MACHINE_VIOLATION",
          "note": "Broader semantic conformance remains outside the machine result."
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "da1a00853fa4d5170013c102d17e8bce85e626ae2ad45cae300ce45c330d92b1",
      "observedA11ViolationCount": 2,
      "observedA11ViolationMessages": [
        "GEAIRM-INV-004: Productness, qualification evidence or AI Primitive identity must not be explicitly equated with AI Product identity."
      ]
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SHACL-003",
      "category": "A6_EXECUTABLE_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "dependsOn incorrectly declared transitive",
      "inputFile": "negative/shacl/a6-003-dependson-incorrectly-declared-transitive.ttl",
      "applicableInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-013",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "RDF_TURTLE_PARSE",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "dataBaseline": "../geairm-0.1.ttl + fixture",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL",
          "expectedInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-013"
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "NOT_REQUIRED_TO_ESTABLISH_THIS_EXPLICIT_MACHINE_VIOLATION",
          "note": "Broader semantic conformance remains outside the machine result."
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "13ebf2b2559c372ddc8962fb007066eccf68dd7bda4b1ac7fce65435bf850e99",
      "observedA11ViolationCount": 1,
      "observedA11ViolationMessages": [
        "GEAIRM-INV-013: aips:dependsOn must not be declared universally transitive."
      ]
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SHACL-004",
      "category": "A6_EXECUTABLE_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Composition explicitly equated with Product",
      "inputFile": "negative/shacl/a6-004-composition-explicitly-equated-with-product.ttl",
      "applicableInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-015",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "RDF_TURTLE_PARSE",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "dataBaseline": "../geairm-0.1.ttl + fixture",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL",
          "expectedInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-015"
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "NOT_REQUIRED_TO_ESTABLISH_THIS_EXPLICIT_MACHINE_VIOLATION",
          "note": "Broader semantic conformance remains outside the machine result."
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "17e2ba4faa8b64f3bead9ad71f1ebc87011537e431c07977381ba8ae7afac3f0",
      "observedA11ViolationCount": 2,
      "observedA11ViolationMessages": [
        "GEAIRM-INV-015: Composition must not be explicitly equated with Product or AI Product identity."
      ]
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SHACL-005",
      "category": "A6_EXECUTABLE_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Delegated Authority explicitly equated with Authorization",
      "inputFile": "negative/shacl/a6-005-delegated-authority-explicitly-equated-with-authorization.ttl",
      "applicableInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-018",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "RDF_TURTLE_PARSE",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "dataBaseline": "../geairm-0.1.ttl + fixture",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL",
          "expectedInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-018"
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "NOT_REQUIRED_TO_ESTABLISH_THIS_EXPLICIT_MACHINE_VIOLATION",
          "note": "Broader semantic conformance remains outside the machine result."
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "2b76178a377f6b79c99fb23366defa016b19dd5814cb8a799cad18f0b0657452",
      "observedA11ViolationCount": 2,
      "observedA11ViolationMessages": [
        "GEAIRM-INV-018: autonomy, control, Delegated Authority and Authorization concepts must not be explicitly equated."
      ]
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SHACL-006",
      "category": "A6_EXECUTABLE_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Sensing explicitly equated with Perception capability",
      "inputFile": "negative/shacl/a6-006-sensing-explicitly-equated-with-perception-capability.ttl",
      "applicableInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-021",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "RDF_TURTLE_PARSE",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "dataBaseline": "../geairm-0.1.ttl + fixture",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL",
          "expectedInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-021"
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "NOT_REQUIRED_TO_ESTABLISH_THIS_EXPLICIT_MACHINE_VIOLATION",
          "note": "Broader semantic conformance remains outside the machine result."
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "cb854cb961b0a5eda909b9a9b8fcd05ccbf4c92a6721abda81a5513846db12c0",
      "observedA11ViolationCount": 2,
      "observedA11ViolationMessages": [
        "GEAIRM-INV-021: Sensing and Perception Intelligence Capability must not be explicitly equated."
      ]
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SHACL-007",
      "category": "A6_EXECUTABLE_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Assurance Finding explicitly equated with Effective Risk Tier",
      "inputFile": "negative/shacl/a6-007-assurance-finding-explicitly-equated-with-effective-risk-tier.ttl",
      "applicableInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-028",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "RDF_TURTLE_PARSE",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "dataBaseline": "../geairm-0.1.ttl + fixture",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL",
          "expectedInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-028"
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "NOT_REQUIRED_TO_ESTABLISH_THIS_EXPLICIT_MACHINE_VIOLATION",
          "note": "Broader semantic conformance remains outside the machine result."
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "3060bc883b16d0e58cbaaa38f4124a2a3b7b603b835f0ae75ea1b8c1ea3f48bb",
      "observedA11ViolationCount": 2,
      "observedA11ViolationMessages": [
        "GEAIRM-INV-028: Assurance Finding and Effective Risk Tier must not be explicitly equated."
      ]
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SHACL-008",
      "category": "A6_EXECUTABLE_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "supersedes incorrectly declared symmetric",
      "inputFile": "negative/shacl/a6-008-supersedes-incorrectly-declared-symmetric.ttl",
      "applicableInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-034",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "RDF_TURTLE_PARSE",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "dataBaseline": "../geairm-0.1.ttl + fixture",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL",
          "expectedInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-034"
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "NOT_REQUIRED_TO_ESTABLISH_THIS_EXPLICIT_MACHINE_VIOLATION",
          "note": "Broader semantic conformance remains outside the machine result."
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "8836c56465b08b966757cd77c25e112148e83fd3b484d8905bfd5af352097329",
      "observedA11ViolationCount": 1,
      "observedA11ViolationMessages": [
        "GEAIRM-INV-034: supersedes must not be declared symmetric or reflexive; supersession preserves directed historical succession."
      ]
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SHACL-009",
      "category": "A6_EXECUTABLE_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "derivedFrom explicitly equated with dependsOn",
      "inputFile": "negative/shacl/a6-009-derivedfrom-explicitly-equated-with-dependson.ttl",
      "applicableInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-035",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "RDF_TURTLE_PARSE",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A6_SHACL",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.shacl.ttl",
          "dataBaseline": "../geairm-0.1.ttl + fixture",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL",
          "expectedInvariant": "GEAIRM-INV-035"
        },
        {
          "layer": "SEMANTIC_ASSESSMENT",
          "expectedOutcome": "NOT_REQUIRED_TO_ESTABLISH_THIS_EXPLICIT_MACHINE_VIOLATION",
          "note": "Broader semantic conformance remains outside the machine result."
        }
      ],
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "c17ebe5ec08b61e5013e6eb00df37fc742066b8b4aff72bc5a0f6bf95a2a3df0",
      "observedA11ViolationCount": 2,
      "observedA11ViolationMessages": [
        "GEAIRM-INV-035: derivation provenance must not be explicitly equated with current dependency or material dependency."
      ]
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SCHEMA-001",
      "category": "A7_STRUCTURAL_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Unknown unqualified type RAG must not enter canonical type space",
      "inputFile": "negative/structural/a7-001-unknown-unqualified-type-rag-must-not-enter-canonical-type-space.json",
      "applicableSchema": "A7",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL"
        }
      ],
      "observedSchemaErrorCountAtA11": 1,
      "representativeObservedError": "{'@context': '/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1.context.jsonld', 'id': 'urn:geairm:test:a11:struct', 'type': 'GEAIRMSemanticGraph', 'geairmVersion': '0.1', 'graph': [{'id': 'urn:ex:a11:x', 'type': 'RAG', 'label': 'Boundary test resource'}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas",
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "f3f9a6ca75fbdc7749d1e0020e8446c193824c157881096507887525cb2de82d"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SCHEMA-002",
      "category": "A7_STRUCTURAL_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Unknown reserved geairm type must be rejected",
      "inputFile": "negative/structural/a7-002-unknown-reserved-geairm-type-must-be-rejected.json",
      "applicableSchema": "A7",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL"
        }
      ],
      "observedSchemaErrorCountAtA11": 1,
      "representativeObservedError": "{'@context': '/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1.context.jsonld', 'id': 'urn:geairm:test:a11:struct', 'type': 'GEAIRMSemanticGraph', 'geairmVersion': '0.1', 'graph': [{'id': 'urn:ex:a11:x', 'type': 'geairm:RAG', 'label': 'Boundary test resource'}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas",
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "d27265bfc4e665e8889613a116fc4740a475a56767a56830fbaf98ce9a43cd94"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SCHEMA-003",
      "category": "A7_STRUCTURAL_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Unknown property in reserved geairm namespace must be rejected",
      "inputFile": "negative/structural/a7-003-unknown-property-in-reserved-geairm-namespace-must-be-rejected.json",
      "applicableSchema": "A7",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL"
        }
      ],
      "observedSchemaErrorCountAtA11": 1,
      "representativeObservedError": "{'@context': '/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1.context.jsonld', 'id': 'urn:geairm:test:a11:struct', 'type': 'GEAIRMSemanticGraph', 'geairmVersion': '0.1', 'graph': [{'id': 'urn:ex:a11:x', 'type': 'AIExecution', 'label': 'Boundary test resource', 'geairm:isTrustedGroundingEvidence': True}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas",
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "9b472c05e81e23316830a16eb6f08be6d4446207dbcb552780a7bd08ae67ad0b"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SCHEMA-004",
      "category": "A7_STRUCTURAL_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Wrong GEAIRM version must be rejected",
      "inputFile": "negative/structural/a7-004-wrong-geairm-version-must-be-rejected.json",
      "applicableSchema": "A7",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL"
        }
      ],
      "observedSchemaErrorCountAtA11": 1,
      "representativeObservedError": "{'@context': '/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1.context.jsonld', 'id': 'urn:geairm:test:a11:struct', 'type': 'GEAIRMSemanticGraph', 'geairmVersion': '0.2', 'graph': [{'id': 'urn:ex:a11:x', 'type': 'AIExecution', 'label': 'Boundary test resource'}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas",
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "076c6fa6086cec4992b550f8b3f0c00d663677b7ee594884b8decf6c5f30d15c"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SCHEMA-005",
      "category": "A7_STRUCTURAL_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Semantic resource without type must be rejected",
      "inputFile": "negative/structural/a7-005-semantic-resource-without-type-must-be-rejected.json",
      "applicableSchema": "A7",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL"
        }
      ],
      "observedSchemaErrorCountAtA11": 1,
      "representativeObservedError": "{'@context': '/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1.context.jsonld', 'id': 'urn:geairm:test:a11:struct', 'type': 'GEAIRMSemanticGraph', 'geairmVersion': '0.1', 'graph': [{'id': 'urn:ex:a11:x', 'label': 'Boundary test resource'}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas",
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "75080ab712c6c5cc1aede0ceb6e7565fd82932c42d1afb7181e023b4e79fce09"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SCHEMA-006",
      "category": "A7_STRUCTURAL_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Semantic graph cannot use graph and @graph simultaneously",
      "inputFile": "negative/structural/a7-006-semantic-graph-cannot-use-graph-and-graph-simultaneously.json",
      "applicableSchema": "A7",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A7_STRUCTURAL_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL"
        }
      ],
      "observedSchemaErrorCountAtA11": 1,
      "representativeObservedError": "{'@context': '/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1.context.jsonld', 'id': 'urn:geairm:test:a11:struct', 'type': 'GEAIRMSemanticGraph', 'geairmVersion': '0.1', 'graph': [{'id': 'urn:ex:a11:x', 'type': 'AIExecution', 'label': 'Boundary test resource'}], '@graph': [{'id': 'urn:ex:a11:x', 'type': 'AIExecution', 'label': 'Boundary test resource'}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas",
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "0f6e166aa74d9bd9c738854ec0c5f69e40117f2d0230890dd2f9e670a2273b52"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SCHEMA-007",
      "category": "A8_PROFILE_EXTENSION_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Profile cannot claim canonical GEAIRM namespace",
      "inputFile": "negative/profile/a8-007-profile-cannot-claim-canonical-geairm-namespace.json",
      "applicableSchema": "A8",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A8_PROFILE_EXTENSION_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.profile.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL"
        }
      ],
      "observedSchemaErrorCountAtA11": 1,
      "representativeObservedError": "{'@context': '/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1.context.jsonld', 'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:regulated-autonomous-ai', 'type': 'GEAIRMProfile', 'name': 'Regulated Autonomous AI Profile', 'description': 'Illustrative governed Profile selecting authority, action, evaluation and assurance semantics for regulated autonomous AI use.', 'version': '0.1-example', 'geairmVersion': '0.1', 'profiles': 'https://aips.kivanura.org/spec/aips/geairm/0.1', 'scope': {'name': 'Regulated autonomous AI semantic scope', 'scopeType': 'Domain profile example', 'elements': ['AIExecution', 'DelegatedAuthority', 'Authorization', 'DecisionFormation', 'Evaluation', 'AssuranceAssessment'], 'relationships': ['operatesUnderDelegatedAuthority', 'authorizedBy', 'withinDelegatedAuthority', 'participatesInDecisionFormation', 'usesEvidence']}, 'authority': 'Example Regulatory AI Governance Function', 'namespace': 'https://aips.kivanura.org/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/local/profile/', 'status': 'Illustrative', 'selectedElements': ['AIExecution', 'DelegatedAuthority', 'Authorization', 'DecisionFormation', 'Evaluation', 'AssuranceAssessment'], 'selectedRelationships': ['operatesUnderDelegatedAuthority', 'authorizedBy', 'withinDelegatedAuthority', 'participatesInDecisionFormation', 'usesEvidence'], 'requiredElements': ['Authorization', 'AssuranceAssessment'], 'requiredRelationships': ['authorizedBy', 'usesEvidence'], 'applicability': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:app:decision-authority', 'target': 'GEAIRM-INV-023', 'status': 'Applicable', 'rationale': 'Decision effects and decision authority remain separate in regulated autonomous use.'}], 'cardinalityConstraints': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:card:authorization', 'subject': 'AIExecution', 'relationship': 'authorizedBy', 'minCount': 1, 'rationale': 'Within this illustrative Profile scope, material autonomous executions require a represented authorization relation.', 'validationClass': 'hybrid-assessment'}], 'additionalConstraints': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:constraint:bounded-authority', 'statement': 'Autonomous action shall remain bounded by declared authority and applicable governance constraints.', 'target': 'GEAIRM-INV-018', 'requirementLevel': 'SHALL', 'validationClass': 'hybrid-assessment', 'rationale': 'Profile-specific tightening/explicit application; it does not alter the core invariant.'}], 'externalSpecifications': [{'id': 'https://example.org/spec/aips-reference', 'name': 'AIPS', 'version': '0.1', 'semanticAuthority': 'AIPS', 'conformanceMode': 'Composed', 'notes': 'AIPS Product qualification and governance remain independently authoritative.'}], 'additionalConformanceRequirements': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:req:assurance-evidence', 'statement': 'Applicable autonomous-action scenarios SHALL provide assurance evidence for the declared scope.', 'requirementLevel': 'SHALL', 'validationClass': 'hybrid-assessment', 'appliesTo': ['AssuranceAssessment'], 'evidenceRequired': True}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas",
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "3b095e1ff20bd5203d00729946d9ff48315be520e18df43ced5ae2cbe7a534aa"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SCHEMA-008",
      "category": "A8_PROFILE_EXTENSION_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Extension cannot claim canonical GEAIRM namespace",
      "inputFile": "negative/profile/a8-008-extension-cannot-claim-canonical-geairm-namespace.json",
      "applicableSchema": "A8",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A8_PROFILE_EXTENSION_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.profile.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL"
        }
      ],
      "observedSchemaErrorCountAtA11": 1,
      "representativeObservedError": "{'@context': '/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1.context.jsonld', 'id': 'urn:geairm:example:extension:banking-ai', 'type': 'GEAIRMExtension', 'name': 'Banking AI Semantic Extension', 'description': 'Illustrative local extension adding a banking-specific decision-materiality concept without changing GEAIRM core.', 'version': '0.1-example', 'geairmVersion': '0.1', 'extends': 'https://aips.kivanura.org/spec/aips/geairm/0.1', 'scope': {'name': 'Banking decision semantics', 'scopeType': 'Local extension example', 'elements': ['DecisionFormation', 'Authorization'], 'relationships': ['informsDecisionFormation', 'authorizedBy']}, 'authority': 'Example Bank AI Governance Function', 'namespace': 'https://aips.kivanura.org/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/local/extension/', 'status': 'Illustrative', 'extendsElements': ['DecisionFormation', 'Authorization'], 'extendsRelationships': ['informsDecisionFormation', 'authorizedBy'], 'extensionElements': [{'id': 'https://example.org/geairm/banking/MaterialBankingDecision', 'localName': 'MaterialBankingDecision', 'label': 'Material Banking Decision', 'termKind': 'Concept', 'definition': 'A local banking-domain concept for a decision whose consequences meet a governed materiality threshold.', 'semanticAuthority': 'Example Bank AI Governance Function', 'relatedElements': ['DecisionFormation'], 'status': 'Illustrative'}], 'extensionRelationships': [{'id': 'https://example.org/geairm/banking/requiresSecondLineApproval', 'localName': 'requiresSecondLineApproval', 'label': 'requires second-line approval', 'definition': 'Local banking relationship indicating that a material banking decision requires second-line approval under the extension policy.', 'semanticAuthority': 'Example Bank AI Governance Function', 'subjectExpectation': 'MaterialBankingDecision', 'objectExpectation': 'Authorization', 'status': 'Illustrative'}], 'additionalConstraints': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:extension:constraint:second-line', 'statement': 'Material banking decisions SHALL preserve GEAIRM Decision/Authority separation and require local second-line approval where the extension policy applies.', 'target': 'GEAIRM-INV-023', 'requirementLevel': 'SHALL', 'validationClass': 'assessment-only', 'rationale': 'Local governance specialization without redefining the GEAIRM invariant.'}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas",
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "7c31c5cb7a4099050a80623df25a5ef966a86e324313522f00063f9c7abf24f5"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SCHEMA-009",
      "category": "A8_PROFILE_EXTENSION_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Extension cannot mint a local term with geairm prefix",
      "inputFile": "negative/profile/a8-009-extension-cannot-mint-a-local-term-with-geairm-prefix.json",
      "applicableSchema": "A8",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A8_PROFILE_EXTENSION_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.profile.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL"
        }
      ],
      "observedSchemaErrorCountAtA11": 1,
      "representativeObservedError": "{'@context': '/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1.context.jsonld', 'id': 'urn:geairm:example:extension:banking-ai', 'type': 'GEAIRMExtension', 'name': 'Banking AI Semantic Extension', 'description': 'Illustrative local extension adding a banking-specific decision-materiality concept without changing GEAIRM core.', 'version': '0.1-example', 'geairmVersion': '0.1', 'extends': 'https://aips.kivanura.org/spec/aips/geairm/0.1', 'scope': {'name': 'Banking decision semantics', 'scopeType': 'Local extension example', 'elements': ['DecisionFormation', 'Authorization'], 'relationships': ['informsDecisionFormation', 'authorizedBy']}, 'authority': 'Example Bank AI Governance Function', 'namespace': 'https://example.org/geairm/banking/', 'status': 'Illustrative', 'extendsElements': ['DecisionFormation', 'Authorization'], 'extendsRelationships': ['informsDecisionFormation', 'authorizedBy'], 'extensionElements': [{'id': 'geairm:MaterialBankingDecision', 'localName': 'MaterialBankingDecision', 'label': 'Material Banking Decision', 'termKind': 'Concept', 'definition': 'A local banking-domain concept for a decision whose consequences meet a governed materiality threshold.', 'semanticAuthority': 'Example Bank AI Governance Function', 'relatedElements': ['DecisionFormation'], 'status': 'Illustrative'}], 'extensionRelationships': [{'id': 'https://example.org/geairm/banking/requiresSecondLineApproval', 'localName': 'requiresSecondLineApproval', 'label': 'requires second-line approval', 'definition': 'Local banking relationship indicating that a material banking decision requires second-line approval under the extension policy.', 'semanticAuthority': 'Example Bank AI Governance Function', 'subjectExpectation': 'MaterialBankingDecision', 'objectExpectation': 'Authorization', 'status': 'Illustrative'}], 'additionalConstraints': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:extension:constraint:second-line', 'statement': 'Material banking decisions SHALL preserve GEAIRM Decision/Authority separation and require local second-line approval where the extension policy applies.', 'target': 'GEAIRM-INV-023', 'requirementLevel': 'SHALL', 'validationClass': 'assessment-only', 'rationale': 'Local governance specialization without redefining the GEAIRM invariant.'}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas",
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "4578bd9e1efe695de2b23c99e14b71f60696069b4281d9c17bb948f36b99cb8e"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SCHEMA-010",
      "category": "A8_PROFILE_EXTENSION_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Profile-level deviation or waiver field is prohibited",
      "inputFile": "negative/profile/a8-010-profile-level-deviation-or-waiver-field-is-prohibited.json",
      "applicableSchema": "A8",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A8_PROFILE_EXTENSION_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.profile.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL"
        }
      ],
      "observedSchemaErrorCountAtA11": 1,
      "representativeObservedError": "{'@context': '/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1.context.jsonld', 'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:regulated-autonomous-ai', 'type': 'GEAIRMProfile', 'name': 'Regulated Autonomous AI Profile', 'description': 'Illustrative governed Profile selecting authority, action, evaluation and assurance semantics for regulated autonomous AI use.', 'version': '0.1-example', 'geairmVersion': '0.1', 'profiles': 'https://aips.kivanura.org/spec/aips/geairm/0.1', 'scope': {'name': 'Regulated autonomous AI semantic scope', 'scopeType': 'Domain profile example', 'elements': ['AIExecution', 'DelegatedAuthority', 'Authorization', 'DecisionFormation', 'Evaluation', 'AssuranceAssessment'], 'relationships': ['operatesUnderDelegatedAuthority', 'authorizedBy', 'withinDelegatedAuthority', 'participatesInDecisionFormation', 'usesEvidence']}, 'authority': 'Example Regulatory AI Governance Function', 'namespace': 'https://example.org/geairm/profile/regulated-autonomous-ai/', 'status': 'Illustrative', 'selectedElements': ['AIExecution', 'DelegatedAuthority', 'Authorization', 'DecisionFormation', 'Evaluation', 'AssuranceAssessment'], 'selectedRelationships': ['operatesUnderDelegatedAuthority', 'authorizedBy', 'withinDelegatedAuthority', 'participatesInDecisionFormation', 'usesEvidence'], 'requiredElements': ['Authorization', 'AssuranceAssessment'], 'requiredRelationships': ['authorizedBy', 'usesEvidence'], 'applicability': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:app:decision-authority', 'target': 'GEAIRM-INV-023', 'status': 'Applicable', 'rationale': 'Decision effects and decision authority remain separate in regulated autonomous use.'}], 'cardinalityConstraints': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:card:authorization', 'subject': 'AIExecution', 'relationship': 'authorizedBy', 'minCount': 1, 'rationale': 'Within this illustrative Profile scope, material autonomous executions require a represented authorization relation.', 'validationClass': 'hybrid-assessment'}], 'additionalConstraints': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:constraint:bounded-authority', 'statement': 'Autonomous action shall remain bounded by declared authority and applicable governance constraints.', 'target': 'GEAIRM-INV-018', 'requirementLevel': 'SHALL', 'validationClass': 'hybrid-assessment', 'rationale': 'Profile-specific tightening/explicit application; it does not alter the core invariant.'}], 'externalSpecifications': [{'id': 'https://example.org/spec/aips-reference', 'name': 'AIPS', 'version': '0.1', 'semanticAuthority': 'AIPS', 'conformanceMode': 'Composed', 'notes': 'AIPS Product qualification and governance remain independently authoritative.'}], 'additionalConformanceRequirements': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:req:assurance-evidence', 'statement': 'Applicable autonomous-action scenarios SHALL provide assurance evidence for the declared scope.', 'requirementLevel': 'SHALL', 'validationClass': 'hybrid-assessment', 'appliesTo': ['AssuranceAssessment'], 'evidenceRequired': True}], 'deviations': [{'target': 'GEAIRM-INV-018', 'waiver': True}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas",
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "01ac72c56dded01017f2a7b9224c30983f578c64d2ec60e4a83c744320062800"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SCHEMA-011",
      "category": "A8_PROFILE_EXTENSION_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "Profile cannot weaken requirement level to MAY",
      "inputFile": "negative/profile/a8-011-profile-cannot-weaken-requirement-level-to-may.json",
      "applicableSchema": "A8",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A8_PROFILE_EXTENSION_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.profile.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL"
        }
      ],
      "observedSchemaErrorCountAtA11": 1,
      "representativeObservedError": "{'@context': '/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1.context.jsonld', 'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:regulated-autonomous-ai', 'type': 'GEAIRMProfile', 'name': 'Regulated Autonomous AI Profile', 'description': 'Illustrative governed Profile selecting authority, action, evaluation and assurance semantics for regulated autonomous AI use.', 'version': '0.1-example', 'geairmVersion': '0.1', 'profiles': 'https://aips.kivanura.org/spec/aips/geairm/0.1', 'scope': {'name': 'Regulated autonomous AI semantic scope', 'scopeType': 'Domain profile example', 'elements': ['AIExecution', 'DelegatedAuthority', 'Authorization', 'DecisionFormation', 'Evaluation', 'AssuranceAssessment'], 'relationships': ['operatesUnderDelegatedAuthority', 'authorizedBy', 'withinDelegatedAuthority', 'participatesInDecisionFormation', 'usesEvidence']}, 'authority': 'Example Regulatory AI Governance Function', 'namespace': 'https://example.org/geairm/profile/regulated-autonomous-ai/', 'status': 'Illustrative', 'selectedElements': ['AIExecution', 'DelegatedAuthority', 'Authorization', 'DecisionFormation', 'Evaluation', 'AssuranceAssessment'], 'selectedRelationships': ['operatesUnderDelegatedAuthority', 'authorizedBy', 'withinDelegatedAuthority', 'participatesInDecisionFormation', 'usesEvidence'], 'requiredElements': ['Authorization', 'AssuranceAssessment'], 'requiredRelationships': ['authorizedBy', 'usesEvidence'], 'applicability': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:app:decision-authority', 'target': 'GEAIRM-INV-023', 'status': 'Applicable', 'rationale': 'Decision effects and decision authority remain separate in regulated autonomous use.'}], 'cardinalityConstraints': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:card:authorization', 'subject': 'AIExecution', 'relationship': 'authorizedBy', 'minCount': 1, 'rationale': 'Within this illustrative Profile scope, material autonomous executions require a represented authorization relation.', 'validationClass': 'hybrid-assessment'}], 'additionalConstraints': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:constraint:bounded-authority', 'statement': 'Autonomous action shall remain bounded by declared authority and applicable governance constraints.', 'target': 'GEAIRM-INV-018', 'requirementLevel': 'MAY', 'validationClass': 'hybrid-assessment', 'rationale': 'Profile-specific tightening/explicit application; it does not alter the core invariant.'}], 'externalSpecifications': [{'id': 'https://example.org/spec/aips-reference', 'name': 'AIPS', 'version': '0.1', 'semanticAuthority': 'AIPS', 'conformanceMode': 'Composed', 'notes': 'AIPS Product qualification and governance remain independently authoritative.'}], 'additionalConformanceRequirements': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:req:assurance-evidence', 'statement': 'Applicable autonomous-action scenarios SHALL provide assurance evidence for the declared scope.', 'requirementLevel': 'SHALL', 'validationClass': 'hybrid-assessment', 'appliesTo': ['AssuranceAssessment'], 'evidenceRequired': True}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas",
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "2e6aa9ff107c713bf23b95868d5912f392f5743a24bbbd07288e913ef71a0a6a"
    },
    {
      "testcaseId": "GEAIRM-A11-SCHEMA-012",
      "category": "A8_PROFILE_EXTENSION_BOUNDARY",
      "title": "NotApplicable Profile rule requires rationale",
      "inputFile": "negative/profile/a8-012-notapplicable-profile-rule-requires-rationale.json",
      "applicableSchema": "A8",
      "expectedLayers": [
        {
          "layer": "JSON_SYNTAX",
          "expectedOutcome": "PASS"
        },
        {
          "layer": "A8_PROFILE_EXTENSION_SCHEMA",
          "artifact": "../geairm-0.1.profile.schema.json",
          "expectedOutcome": "FAIL"
        }
      ],
      "observedSchemaErrorCountAtA11": 1,
      "representativeObservedError": "{'@context': '/spec/aips/geairm/0.1/geairm-0.1.context.jsonld', 'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:regulated-autonomous-ai', 'type': 'GEAIRMProfile', 'name': 'Regulated Autonomous AI Profile', 'description': 'Illustrative governed Profile selecting authority, action, evaluation and assurance semantics for regulated autonomous AI use.', 'version': '0.1-example', 'geairmVersion': '0.1', 'profiles': 'https://aips.kivanura.org/spec/aips/geairm/0.1', 'scope': {'name': 'Regulated autonomous AI semantic scope', 'scopeType': 'Domain profile example', 'elements': ['AIExecution', 'DelegatedAuthority', 'Authorization', 'DecisionFormation', 'Evaluation', 'AssuranceAssessment'], 'relationships': ['operatesUnderDelegatedAuthority', 'authorizedBy', 'withinDelegatedAuthority', 'participatesInDecisionFormation', 'usesEvidence']}, 'authority': 'Example Regulatory AI Governance Function', 'namespace': 'https://example.org/geairm/profile/regulated-autonomous-ai/', 'status': 'Illustrative', 'selectedElements': ['AIExecution', 'DelegatedAuthority', 'Authorization', 'DecisionFormation', 'Evaluation', 'AssuranceAssessment'], 'selectedRelationships': ['operatesUnderDelegatedAuthority', 'authorizedBy', 'withinDelegatedAuthority', 'participatesInDecisionFormation', 'usesEvidence'], 'requiredElements': ['Authorization', 'AssuranceAssessment'], 'requiredRelationships': ['authorizedBy', 'usesEvidence'], 'applicability': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:test:a11:profile:notapplicable', 'target': 'GEAIRM-INV-023', 'status': 'NotApplicable'}], 'cardinalityConstraints': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:card:authorization', 'subject': 'AIExecution', 'relationship': 'authorizedBy', 'minCount': 1, 'rationale': 'Within this illustrative Profile scope, material autonomous executions require a represented authorization relation.', 'validationClass': 'hybrid-assessment'}], 'additionalConstraints': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:constraint:bounded-authority', 'statement': 'Autonomous action shall remain bounded by declared authority and applicable governance constraints.', 'target': 'GEAIRM-INV-018', 'requirementLevel': 'SHALL', 'validationClass': 'hybrid-assessment', 'rationale': 'Profile-specific tightening/explicit application; it does not alter the core invariant.'}], 'externalSpecifications': [{'id': 'https://example.org/spec/aips-reference', 'name': 'AIPS', 'version': '0.1', 'semanticAuthority': 'AIPS', 'conformanceMode': 'Composed', 'notes': 'AIPS Product qualification and governance remain independently authoritative.'}], 'additionalConformanceRequirements': [{'id': 'urn:geairm:example:profile:req:assurance-evidence', 'statement': 'Applicable autonomous-action scenarios SHALL provide assurance evidence for the declared scope.', 'requirementLevel': 'SHALL', 'validationClass': 'hybrid-assessment', 'appliesTo': ['AssuranceAssessment'], 'evidenceRequired': True}]} is not valid under any of the given schemas",
      "overallExpectedOutcome": "REJECT",
      "inputSha256": "17194c24032a6ef14c9c113a69407feb4c1038c1b9f79a9facbbe0d8f8c05588"
    }
  ]
}
