Skip to main content

AIPCH10 — Compliant by Design

“Policy-as-Code and Governance Controls Enforced”


What AIPCH10 is really asserting​

AIPCH10 is not asserting that:

“The AI Product complies with regulations or policies.”

It is asserting that:

All applicable governance requirements (regulatory, ethical, risk, access, and usage constraints) are explicitly defined, bound to the AI Product at creation time, and automatically enforced at runtime through policy-as-code — without relying on manual processes or human interpretation.

Compliance is not a review outcome.
Compliance is a continuously enforced system property.


The Essence (HDIP + AIPS Interpretation)​

An AI Product is compliant by design if and only if:

  1. Governance policies are declared alongside the product intent
  2. Policies are bound to the product during compilation
  3. Enforcement is automatic, consistent, and runtime-driven

If compliance depends on:

  • manual approvals
  • audits after deployment
  • documentation or sign-offs
  • human interpretation of rules

then AIPCH10 is not met, even if the product is “compliant”.


The Governance Model (Federated Computational Governance)​

AIPCH10 operates through:

Federated, hierarchical policy enforcement

Policies are defined at multiple levels:

  • Global (enterprise-wide rules)
  • Domain (e.g., Risk, Compliance, Legal)
  • Product (AIPRO-defined constraints)

These are:

  • visible to the AIPRO during design
  • compiled into the product
  • enforced automatically at runtime

Positive Criteria — When AIPCH10 is met​

AIPCH10 is met when all of the following are true:


1. Policies are explicitly declared and bound at design time​

The AI Product includes:

  • risk classification (R0–R4)
  • data usage constraints (privacy, residency)
  • ethical constraints (fairness, bias thresholds)
  • access and entitlement policies
  • usage boundaries (allowed/prohibited use)

These are:

  • part of the declarative definition
  • not external or implicit

2. Policy enforcement is automatic at runtime​

The system enforces:

  • access controls (RBAC, ABAC, ReBAC, etc.)
  • data filtering (row/column-level controls)
  • usage restrictions
  • risk-based constraints
  • compliance checks (e.g., GDPR, fairness thresholds)

No manual intervention is required.


3. Governance is enforced consistently across all consumers​

The AI Product:

  • behaves consistently regardless of who consumes it
  • does not rely on consumer-specific controls
  • enforces policies at the product level

This ensures:

governance travels with the product


4. Policies are machine-interpretable and executable​

Policies are:

  • defined as structured artifacts (policy-as-code)
  • interpretable by the platform
  • enforceable without human translation

This enables:

  • automated compliance
  • agent-driven governance

5. Policy violations are detectable and observable​

The system:

  • detects violations (e.g., misuse, threshold breaches)
  • logs and exposes them as signals (linked to AIPCH07)
  • triggers enforcement or escalation actions

Negative Criteria — When AIPCH10 is not met​

AIPCH10 is not met if any of the following are true:


❌ Compliance relies on manual processes​

Examples:

  • approval workflows before deployment
  • compliance reviews after release
  • human sign-offs for policy enforcement

This is governance by process, not by design.


❌ Policies are documented but not enforced​

Examples:

  • “Do not use for X” in documentation
  • compliance guidelines without system enforcement
  • ethical policies without runtime checks

This creates policy illusion.


❌ Enforcement depends on consuming systems​

Examples:

  • access control implemented in client applications
  • policy checks delegated to downstream systems
  • inconsistent enforcement across consumers

This breaks product-level governance.


❌ Policies are not visible to the AIPRO​

Examples:

  • hidden governance logic
  • unclear constraints during product definition
  • policies applied after deployment

This prevents intentional design.


Edge Cases (Important Guidance for Agents)​


Case 1: “Manual compliance approval required before deployment”​

❌ Not met

Rationale:

  • compliance is procedural
  • not embedded in system behavior

Case 2: “Policy enforcement exists but incomplete coverage”​

⚠️ Partial

Rationale:

  • some controls enforced
  • gaps remain (e.g., fairness, misuse detection)

Case 3: “Policy-as-code with automatic runtime enforcement”​

✅ Met

Rationale:

  • policies declared, bound, and enforced
  • no manual dependency

Case 4: “High-risk AI (R3/R4) with human oversight layer”​

✅ Met, if:

  • oversight is part of policy enforcement
  • not a replacement for system-level controls

Evidence Signals an Agent Should Look For​


Authoritative evidence:​

  • policy artifacts linked to AIPROD/AIPDS
  • runtime enforcement logs
  • entitlement and access control configuration
  • risk tier classification

Supporting evidence:​

  • violation detection signals (linked to AIPCH07)
  • audit trails of enforcement actions
  • policy evaluation results

Red flags:​

  • reliance on documentation or guidelines
  • manual approval workflows
  • inconsistent enforcement across consumers
  • lack of runtime policy signals

How an AI Agent Should Decide​

Decision rule (simplified):

If governance and compliance depend on manual processes, documentation, or human interpretation rather than automated, runtime policy enforcement, AIPCH10 is not met.


Why AIPCH10 Is Non-Negotiable​

Without AIPCH10:

  • governance becomes inconsistent
  • risk cannot be controlled at scale
  • compliance becomes reactive
  • trust (AIPCH07) becomes unreliable

AIPCH10 enables:

  • continuous, enforceable governance
  • scalable compliance without committees
  • safe reuse and composition
  • alignment with regulatory expectations

Canonical Statement (for AIPS)​

AIPCH10 is satisfied only when all applicable governance and compliance requirements are explicitly declared, bound to the AI Product during creation, and automatically enforced at runtime through machine-interpretable policy-as-code, without reliance on manual processes or human interpretation.