AIPCH20 — Interoperable & Composable
“The AI Product can participate safely in governed multi-product use and composition through stable semantic contracts.”
What AIPCH20 is really asserting
AIPCH20 distinguishes interoperability/composability from Productized Composition.
An AI Product may be:
- directly consumed;
- used alongside other Products in federated/orchestrated consumption;
- used as an upstream dependency in a new Product.
Only the last case creates a new Product, and it creates a Derived AI Product only when a distinct governed intelligence proposition materially depends on upstream AI Product intelligence.
Composition behavior does not automatically create another AI Product.
Positive criteria
AIPCH20 is Met when:
- governed ports and contracts are stable and machine-understandable;
- semantics align sufficiently for safe combination;
- dependency and policy boundaries survive composition;
- ordinary orchestration does not hide Product ownership/currentness;
- Productized Composition establishes a new owner, Product identity, AQE and APT where a new AI Product is created;
- no consumer needs knowledge of internal implementation to use the Product correctly.
Not Met
Examples include:
- bespoke glue code is required for every integration;
- semantic mismatch creates unsafe interpretation;
- upstream Product trust/policy boundaries disappear in orchestration;
- a router/orchestrator is incorrectly registered as a Derived AI Product without a distinct intelligence proposition;
- a genuine Derived AI Product has no explicit dependency topology.
Evidence signals
- consumption ports and schemas;
- ontology/semantic mappings;
- dependency graph and currentness;
- APT/derivation topology for Productized Composition;
- governance/policy inheritance and composition tests.
Agent decision rule
Met when the Product can be safely used in larger governed compositions while preserving Product boundaries, and where creation of a new Derived AI Product is distinguished from ordinary orchestration or federated consumption.