AIPCH04 — Declarative Intelligence Definition & Compilation
“The AI Product is expressed declaratively and compiled into implementation without requiring the creator to engineer the realization.”
What AIPCH04 is really asserting
AIPCH04 is about declarative Product definition and platform compilation.
It does not assert that every AI Product must be Derived or compositionally depend on upstream AI Products.
A Primary AI Product can satisfy AIPCH04 by declaratively expressing its intent, intelligence behavior, constraints, dependencies, and evolution posture. A Derived AI Product can additionally declare upstream AI Product dependencies and composition semantics.
Relationship to AIPCH03
| Characteristic | Focus |
|---|---|
| AIPCH03 | The Product is represented by structured declarative specifications. |
| AIPCH04 | Those declarations are sufficient for the platform to compile the Product realization without a manual translation layer. |
Positive criteria
AIPCH04 is Met when:
- Product intent, intelligence proposition, behavior, constraints, risk expectations, ports, and dependencies are declarative;
- Model Products, AI Primitives, Data Products, upstream AI Products, knowledge/rules, and tools are referenced as governed dependencies where applicable;
- HDIP/PFI resolves implementation and produces the required AIPROD/AIPDS realization;
- governance controls are compiled from the effective Governance Obligation Profile;
- the same versioned declarations are reproducible and auditable.
Not Met
Examples include:
- engineers manually translate Product intent into pipelines or orchestration;
- prompts or code are the only source of behavioral semantics;
- creators must choose infrastructure topology as part of Product intent;
- material dependencies are hidden in implementation rather than declared.
Composition boundary
Declarative composition is relevant where composition exists.
Using multiple dependencies does not by itself create a Derived AI Product. APT becomes Derived only when the distinct intelligence proposition materially depends on upstream AI Product intelligence.
Ordinary orchestration/federated use and Productized Composition remain separate concepts.
Evidence signals
- Intent Record and Stage 3 intelligence constitution;
- IBEC;
- Stage 7 compilation output;
- definitive AQE and APT;
- generated AIPROD/AIPDS;
- absence of ungoverned manual translation steps.
Agent decision rule
Met when the Product can be defined at semantic/intelligence intent level and deterministically compiled into governed realization, with composition semantics included only where the constitution requires them.