Skip to main content

AIPCH18 — Governed Evolution & Adaptation

“The AI Product declares and governs how its intelligence may evolve, including when learning is not part of its constitution.”


What AIPCH18 is really asserting​

AIPCH18 does not require every AI Product to retrain, learn continuously, or exhibit model drift.

It asserts that the Product has an explicit and controlled evolution posture appropriate to its intelligence mechanism.

A valid posture may include:

  • NONE — no learning/adaptation mechanism; evolution occurs only through governed version change;
  • periodic or triggered retraining;
  • fine-tuning;
  • online learning;
  • prompt evolution;
  • rule or knowledge evolution;
  • planner/reasoner configuration evolution;
  • Model Product or AI Primitive replacement;
  • upstream AI Product dependency migration;
  • human-governed adaptation.

Positive criteria​

AIPCH18 is Met when:

  1. AIPDS/IBEC declares the evolution/learning mode explicitly;
  2. allowed evolution mechanisms and triggers are defined;
  3. validation, versioning, rollback and governance controls apply to material changes;
  4. qualification/dependency impact is re-evaluated when constitution changes;
  5. trust and COVP evidence can trigger an appropriate evolution path;
  6. learningMode = NONE is accepted when that accurately reflects the Product constitution.

Examples​

Learned-model AI Product​

Met when retraining/fine-tuning is governed, validated, versioned and observable where applicable.

Symbolic reasoner​

Met with learningMode = NONE plus governed rule/knowledge versioning and change validation. No retraining pipeline is required.

Derived AI Product​

Met when upstream AI Product version migration and qualification impact are explicitly governed.

Physical AI​

Met when changes to control/perception/planning behavior are validated against safety obligations before promotion.


Partial / Not Met​

Partial:

  • evolution mechanism is known but change evidence/rollback/currentness handling is incomplete.

Not Met:

  • Product behavior changes through unmanaged prompts, rules, online learning, model replacement or upstream dependency drift;
  • retraining exists but is not governed/versioned;
  • a Product declares NONE while silently adapting at runtime;
  • constitution changes do not trigger AQE/APT/dependency impact analysis.

Evidence signals​

  • IBEC and AIPDS evolution specification;
  • learning/evolution mode;
  • version/change history;
  • validation and rollback evidence;
  • dependency/currentness events;
  • Continuous Assurance and COVP-triggered change records.

Agent decision rule​

Met when the Product’s evolution posture is explicit, mechanism-appropriate, governed, versioned and capable of preserving qualification, intent, constraints and trust over time. Retraining is conditional, not universal.