Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is an AI Product just a model or model API?
No.
A trained model can be an Artificial Intelligence Primitive and, when independently productized, a Model Product. A generic hosted inference endpoint can be a Model Service Product. Neither becomes an AIPS AI Product solely because it is packaged, governed or exposed through an API.
An AIPS AI Product additionally requires intelligence itself to be the value-bearing essence, a distinct governed intelligence proposition, a governed Product boundary, and current direct/transitive evidence of at least one qualifying AI Primitive.
Can a Model Product be a Business Product?
Yes.
A company such as a hypothetical AI model vendor may sell downloadable learned models as its core Business Products. For that company the Model Product can cross the enterprise value boundary as a commercial offering while remaining ontologically distinct from an AIPS AI Product.
A downstream enterprise can procure the same Model Product as an enabling dependency and use it to construct its own Primary AI Product.
Does an AI Product have to use a trained ML model?
No.
AIPS recognizes multiple qualifying Artificial Intelligence Primitives, including learned models, symbolic reasoners, knowledge reasoners, planners, intelligent search and qualifying hybrid mechanisms.
A symbolic reasoning Product can therefore qualify as a Primary AI Product with no Model Card, training dataset or retraining pipeline.
Why not just treat AI as a Data Product?
Because they productize different value-bearing essences.
- A Data Product productizes governed data/business truth.
- An AI Product productizes governed artificial-intelligence capability.
- An Information Product productizes governed information/meaning for an enduring information need.
They may depend on one another, but dependency does not imply Product-family inheritance. See Why Not a Data Product?.
What is APT?
AI Product Type (APT) classifies the provenance of productized intelligence:
- Primary — no material upstream AI Product dependency;
- Derived — the distinct intelligence proposition materially depends on one or more upstream AI Products.
A Derived Product can have SingleUpstream or Composite derivation topology. Composite is not a peer APT.
If an AI Product calls another AI Product, is it automatically Derived?
No.
Runtime routing, orchestration or federation alone does not establish a new Product. A Derived AI Product exists only when the composition creates a distinct governed intelligence proposition with its own Product boundary and materially depends on upstream AI Product intelligence.
Can an AI Product stop being an AI Product?
A new Product version can lose AI Product Family qualification if its constitution no longer satisfies the AI qualification conditions.
For example, if Product A v1 ultimately depends on a qualifying LLM but Product A v2 replaces its only AI Primitive path with ordinary deterministic if/else logic, v2 must be re-evaluated. Historical v1 remains historically classified as an AI Product; its classification is not rewritten.
Downstream Products are re-evaluated only when their actual version bindings adopt the changed dependency.
Is an AI agent automatically an AI Product?
No.
An agent may be an implementation component, runtime pattern, AI Primitive, orchestrator, or AI Product. It qualifies as an AI Product only when it independently satisfies the Product and AI Product qualification tests.
Agentic is not an APT. Agency/goal-driven interaction and autonomy are represented through MO and AR.
What about Physical AI?
Physical-world perception, actuation and closed-loop autonomous behavior are represented explicitly through Embodiment (EM) and Intelligence Effect (IE).
A robot can be an AI-enabled Physical Product without the whole robot being exclusively an AI Product. A fully autonomous humanoid may be a cross-family Compound Product with co-essential Physical/Engineered and AI contributions, while its Humanoid Intelligence is separately governed as an AI Product.
Does every AI Product have to retrain or continuously learn?
No.
AIPS requires a governed evolution posture, not universal retraining. Depending on the Product, evolution may occur through retraining, fine-tuning, prompt/rule/knowledge updates, component replacement, upstream Product migration, or learningMode = NONE.
Does high usage or business value prove that something is an AI Product?
No.
Usage, ratings, fitness and value-realization evidence belong to COVP. They can trigger assurance or evolution, but they do not determine PIN, Product Family, APT or R0–R4 risk.
Does a low PMDD score mean the thing is an AI Asset?
No.
PMDD measures the maturity of a Product that already has CURRENT AI Qualification Evidence. A low score means Emerging AI Product, not “AI Asset”. If qualification is absent or invalid, the candidate is Not Assessable under PMDD.
What is the difference between AI Product and AI-enabled Product?
An AI Product has artificial intelligence as its value-bearing essence.
An AI-enabled Product belongs intrinsically to another Product Family but materially uses AI. Examples include a streaming service using recommendation AI, a smartphone with an assistant, or an AI-generated movie.
Using AI does not cause automatic Product-family inheritance.
Is self-service mandatory?
AIPS inherits BPS Product principles, including deliberate, governed consumability. “Self-service” does not mean anonymous or uncontrolled access; it means an authorized consumer can discover, understand, acquire/entitle and consume the Product through governed interfaces without bespoke engineering for every consumer.
Principle: AIPS separates Productness, AI Product qualification, intelligence provenance, behavior, risk and maturity so that each claim can be evidenced independently.