Examples
These examples illustrate the ontology-aligned AIPROD structure. They deliberately separate AI Product qualification, AI Product Type (APT), Intelligence Capability (IC), and other orthogonal characteristics.
Example 1 — Fraud Detection Intelligence
Identity
- Product ID:
urn:aiprod:fraud-detection - Version:
2.1.0 - Owner: Enterprise Fraud AI Product Owner
Purpose & Intelligence Proposition
- Purpose: Support payment-fraud identification and investigation prioritization.
- Distinct Intelligence Proposition: Detect and classify transaction fraud risk with evidence suitable for downstream review.
AI Qualification
- Qualification Status: CURRENT
- Value-Bearing Essence: Artificial intelligence
- Qualifying AI Primitive: Registered gradient-boosted fraud Model Product
- Qualification Path:
FraudDetectionAIP@2.1 → FraudModelProduct@4.0
Ontology Dimensions
- APT: Primary
- IC: Detection + Classification + Prediction
- CS: Cross-Division
- PU: Compliance & Risk + Operational Automation
- MO: Real-time / Event-driven
- IE: Fraud score + classification + alert + explanation evidence
- AR: Recommend
- EM: Non-embodied
- RT: AIPS risk tier as assessed
Dependencies
- Payment Lifecycle Data Product
- Fraud History Data Product
- Fraud Model Product
- Threshold/policy rules
The Product is Primary, not Derived, because it has no material upstream AI Product dependency even though it depends on multiple Data Products and a Model Product.
Example 2 — Enterprise Research Assistant
Identity
- Product ID:
urn:aiprod:research-assistant - Version:
1.0.0 - Owner: Knowledge Systems AI Product Owner
Purpose & Intelligence Proposition
- Purpose: Support researchers in finding, reasoning over, synthesizing, and drafting evidence-backed research outputs.
- Distinct Intelligence Proposition: Reason over governed research sources and generate evidence-linked research assistance.
AI Qualification
- Qualification Status: CURRENT
- Qualifying AI Primitives: Procured LLM Model Product + embedding/search primitive
Ontology Dimensions
- APT: Primary
- IC: Reasoning + Generation + Recommendation + Planning
- MO: Interactive + Agentic / Goal-driven
- IE: Generated report + evidence + recommended next steps
- AR: Assist
- EM: Non-embodied
A Model Product dependency does not make this Product Derived. The intelligence proposition is constituted directly from AI Primitives, governed knowledge, tools, and controls.
Example 3 — Integrated Transaction Risk Intelligence
Identity
- Product ID:
urn:aiprod:transaction-risk - Version:
3.0.0
Distinct Intelligence Proposition
Provide a governed integrated assessment of transaction risk by synthesizing multiple specialist intelligence Products.
Upstream AI Product Dependencies
- Fraud Detection AI Product
- Sanctions Intelligence AI Product
- Behavioural Risk AI Product
Classification
- AI Qualification: CURRENT
- APT: Derived
- Derivation Topology: Composite
- IC: Reasoning + Classification + Recommendation
- IE: Integrated risk assessment + evidence + recommendation
This is a Derived AI Product because the new intelligence proposition materially depends on upstream AI Products. Composite describes the derivation topology and is not a peer APT.
Example 4 — Symbolic Policy Reasoner
Identity
- Product ID:
urn:aiprod:policy-reasoner - Version:
1.3.0
Qualification
- Value-Bearing Essence: Governed reasoning intelligence
- AI Primitive: Symbolic inference engine
- Knowledge Dependencies: Governed policy ontology + versioned rules
- APT: Primary
- IC: Reasoning + Classification
This Product demonstrates that a trained machine-learning model is not a universal requirement for AI Product qualification.
Boundary Example — Productized LLM Model
Consider a downloadable, governed Qwen-like LLM sold through a model marketplace.
It may be:
- a fully productized Model Product;
- the model vendor's Business Product;
- a qualifying AI Primitive used by many downstream AI Products.
It is not automatically an AIPS AI Product merely because it is a Product in the AI domain.
Summary
These examples show that:
- Productized models and AI Products are distinct concepts;
- APT depends on upstream AI Product intelligence provenance, not the number of models or Data Products involved;
- Intelligence Capability is multi-valued;
- symbolic and learned mechanisms can both qualify as AI Primitives;
- Derived/Composite semantics require a new governed intelligence proposition.
Principle: AIPROD should let a consumer understand what intelligence is offered, why the Product qualifies as AI, and where that intelligence comes from.