Skip to main content

Product Family Boundaries in the Marketplace

Marketplace taxonomies are especially vulnerable to AI-washing. AIPS therefore requires the listing layer to preserve the Product ontology established by PIN and AI Qualification.

AI Product​

An AI Product listing represents a Product version whose value-bearing essence is a distinct artificial-intelligence capability and whose current constitution contains a qualifying AI Primitive path.

An active AI Product listing must expose:

  • exact Product identity and version;
  • current AI Qualification status;
  • APT;
  • IC / CS / PU / MO / IE / AR / EM;
  • effective R0-R4 risk;
  • AIPS-DPP reference;
  • trust/currentness summary;
  • access and consumption-port metadata.

Model Product​

A Model Product is a Product whose value-bearing essence is a reusable learned computational capability embodied in a governed model artifact or package.

A Model Product can be a Business Product for an organization such as AIModelCo while remaining distinct from an AIPS AI Product.

A Model Product listing must not be assigned:

  • APT;
  • AI Product Qualification status;
  • Derived/Primary AI Product semantics.

It may instead expose model-specific information such as:

  • model identity/version;
  • primitive type;
  • capability/use-case summary;
  • artifact/package reference;
  • Model Card where applicable;
  • license and hosting constraints.

AI-enabled Product​

An AI-enabled Product has another intrinsic Product Family while AI contributes materially to its construction or operation.

Examples:

  • a Service Product using recommendation AI;
  • a Physical Product with an AI assistant;
  • a Movie Product created with generative AI.

The marketplace must expose the actual intrinsic Product Family and the AI contribution role. It must not promote the whole Product into the AI Product Family merely because it uses AI.

Compound Products​

A cross-family Compound Product may have AI as a co-essential intrinsic family contribution, for example a fully autonomous humanoid product with both Physical/Engineered and AI contributions.

The complete Compound Product and its embedded or separately governed AI Product are distinct catalog subjects and may each have their own Product identity, lifecycle, and trust artifacts.

Non-inheritance rule​

A marketplace listing does not inherit Product Family from its dependencies.

Using a Model Product does not automatically make the consumer Product an AI Product. Using an AI Product does not automatically make a Service, Movie, Smartphone, or Robot an AI Product.